Best ice cream

in indy

Locally Sourced × Deliberately Crafted


Located in the wooded Geist area for the last 25 years, Sundae’s Homemade will redefine your relationship with ice cream.


Sundae’s Homemade opened in December 1995 and is located at the southern tip of the Geist Reservoir in Indianapolis. Over the last number of years, the store has perfected the homemade ice cream craft and mastered the art of coffee roasting. Come into the store to discover some of Sundae’s staple flavors like Graham Central Station, Lemoreo, Key Lime Pie, or Chocolate Peanut Butter Brownie.

Sundae’s delivers ice cream to restaurants all across the Midwest, participates in local fundraisers, caters weddings, open houses, and office events. Sundae’s has won multiple awards for Indy’s best ice cream because we use only the highest quality ingredients to produce our dense and creamy frozen flavors. With over 30 years of experience in the ice cream industry, we have mastered classic recipes and continue to innovate new flavors. Sundae’s still makes it the old fashioned way, one batch at a time.






9922 East 79th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46256



M-Th 11a–10p
F-Sa 11a–11p
Su 12p–10p


Ice Cream Flavors

Interested in one of the below topics? Use the form below to send us an email.

  • Purchasing tubs or prepacked cups of Sundae’s Ice Cream

  • Catering for weddings, open houses, office events, etc.

  • Fundraisers, employment opportunities, & other inquiries

Name *
Please select your topic of interest

(317) 570-0533